How to Choose a Hernia Surgeon
Ten questions to ask at your consultation
Choosing a hernia surgeon starts with understanding your options and finding a team that explains them clearly. Bring these ten questions to your consultation, and consider a second opinion if you would like help comparing recommendations.
1. What are your qualifications and hernia training?
Ask about board certification in general surgery and fellowship training in hernia, abdominal wall, or minimally invasive surgery.
2. How often do you repair hernias like mine?
Ask about experience with your type of hernia, including recurrent or complex repairs when relevant.
3. Which repair do you recommend, and why?
Your surgeon should explain how the size and location of your hernia, your health, and your preferences affect the recommendation. Ask about alternatives, including whether monitoring is appropriate.
4. What are the differences between robotic, laparoscopic, and open repair?
Ask which approaches are suitable for you and what benefits, risks, and limitations each has. The choice should reflect your individual needs.
5. Is mesh-free repair an option for me?
Discuss mesh and mesh-free repair, including the Shouldice procedure for selected inguinal hernias. Ask how each option affects the chance of recurrence and other complications.
6. What if my hernia has returned or I have concerns about mesh?
Ask about evaluation for recurrent hernias, abdominal wall reconstruction, and mesh complications. Mesh removal requires a careful assessment and is not appropriate for everyone.
7. What should I expect during recovery?
Ask when you can walk, drive, return to work, lift, and exercise. Your plan should account for your repair and daily activities.
8. What are the risks of the operation?
Discuss infection, bleeding, recurrence, persistent pain, and other risks relevant to your health and procedure. Ask how the team measures and follows outcomes.
9. Where will surgery take place, and who will care for me?
Confirm the surgical facility, anesthesia arrangements, and the team responsible for follow-up. Your consultation and surgery may take place at different locations.
10. How do insurance and follow-up work?
Confirm coverage with your insurer and the office. Ask about costs, follow-up appointments, and how to reach the team if you have a concern.
Meet the Hernia Experts
Our Columbia Hernia Center team offers robotic, laparoscopic, and open repair, mesh-free options for selected patients, and care for complex hernias and mesh complications.
Meet our team or learn about mesh-free repair, abdominal wall reconstruction, and our Mesh Removal Program.
Schedule a consultation
New York City (212) 305-5947
New Jersey (212) 305-2038